Last year I was slow in discovering the television phenomena of the year. Glee was the talk of TV critics and fans everywhere. The music was catchy, the stories cute and smart, the stars also cute. Everyone was watching it and buzzing about it all over the social networks. And I must say, I was hooked. I started watching near the end of the first half of season one, and saw most of the second half. I thought (and still do) that the season finale was some of the most amazing television I'd seen in years.
Now we are six episodes in to season 2 (after tonight) and with the exception of the Rocky Horror Episode, I am not impressed. Seems that this High School hit has hit a sophomore slump. Let me tell you the problems I see. And for comparison I will refer to another favorite of mine that suffered the dreaded slump, Heroes. A few years back Heroes debuted as the hot property on NBC. After an amazing first year, it attempted to come back, bigger and better. It's first problem was adding too many new characters; Glee is doing the same thing. We don't need the new tough girl football coach, we don't need the bleached-blond new quarter back. We don't need the girl who was scared away by Rachel, but is sure to be back when they face Vocal Adrenaline in regionals. We liked the original cast, lets keep them.
A second problem Heroes had in season two is that they lost the individual episode appeal by aiming at too grand a climax of the season (unfortunately the writer's strike cut the season short before it could reach the grand climax). I feel Glee may be falling into the same trap, shooting for Nationals in New York; I think they need to get us interested in the kids again, or we (that is I) may tune out before NY.
The first season was filled with what I call "WoW" moments; things that made me say "That was amazing...haven't seen that before". And there were moments that brought goosebumps to my skin, this is something that has to be spontaneous, I can't make the goosebumps happen. So far this season I only got a tiny bit of goosebumps during the episode where Kurt's father is in the coma. You would think it would have been any of the pseudo-religious songs or sequences, but it was when Kurt sang "I want to hold your hand". That scene got to me. And as for "Wow" moments, I hold the Rocky Horror episode as a WOW episode, but no individual moments this season.
And the biggest thing that is plaguing Glee this season is the cast apparent lack of the ability to keep it's clothes on in magazines. A GQ spread featuring 3 of the very attractive stars in skimpy clothes stirred up a controversy, followed a few weeks later by a solo photo shoot of one of the stars topless (not really showing anything bad). But of course these photo shoots stirred up an uproar from family groups about the inappropriateness of "high school students" posing his way. The point was raised that the actors were not actually high school age. My view is, yes they had the right to pose this way, no big deal; but it has taken focus off the show, and any message the show may be putting out, and has put focus on the behavior of the cast. If the cast wanted to help the show, and get the message out the should have done a photo shoot of the whole cast, not just the hotties, showing what beautiful PEOPLE they are, not on the outside, but within. Ok, so I'm stretching the theme of the show, and trying to get it to spill over into real life, so shoot me.
Anyway, Glee cast and writers need to refocus on what they had first season and try to bring it back, or the magic is gonna fade. They will start losing viewers if season 2 doesn't pick it up soon. ...Oops, gotta run, almost time for GLEE!!!